On this episode of North State Rocks, Jessica Vigil, from Elwood Ranch and a North State native who grew up on Dixie Valley Ranch, sat down with Perry Thompson to discuss a crisis threatening generational ranching operations: wolf predation. This isn't a conversation about wildlife conservation in the abstract. It's about real families facing real losses and a policy framework that often leaves them with no legal way to defend themselves.
The Policy Problem
During California's Phase One (2020–2025), ranchers were prohibited from hazing wolves directly. No noise, no deterrents. Nothing. This inadvertently trained wolves to see human presence as non-threatening. Today, wolves walk past houses and treat cattle ranches as easy meals.
Phase Two allows drones and spotlights but prohibits non-lethal deterrents like rubber bullets, measures that are legal in Oregon and Washington.
“The wolves have already learned there's no negative interaction with humans,” Jessica explained. They've adapted by hunting at night, when ranchers can't be everywhere at once.
The Hidden Costs
Only about one in seven wolf kills gets officially recorded. For confirmation, trappers must find specific evidence; scavenged carcasses don't count. The official numbers look manageable. The actual losses are staggering.
Beyond direct kills are “unrealized losses.” A cow killed in her prime would produce many more calves in her lifetime. Replacement heifers now cost $5,200+. When herds live under constant predation pressure, conception rates fall 20–30%, and weight gain drops 3–5%. The operation becomes defensive, not productive.
Wolves also target the bloodline deliberately, including calves, nursing cows, and heifers. These represent years of genetic development. When a heifer bred for specific traits dies, it's not just money lost; it's generational progress erased.
Ranchers Caught Between Compassion and Survival
The truly unbearable part is the legal handcuff. California law carries potential jail time for harming a wolf, even in self-defense. Ranchers watch cattle die repeatedly while facing felony charges if they act.
Federal trappers work seven days a week investigating kills, emotionally affected by what they see. They're overworked and overwhelmed. Meanwhile, California taxpayers fund wolf management, hazing teams, and trappers, but ranchers navigate the system alone to recover a fraction of their losses.
A Solution Emerges
Rather than give up, Jessica and other ranchers launched Ranches with Wolves, a nonprofit supporting ranchers through education, fundraising, and cost-sharing for fencing and management changes. Direct reimbursement covers the dead animal, not infrastructure, stress losses, or operational modifications. The nonprofit addresses what the state doesn't.
“We saw the need because you are only reimbursed for the actual loss of the animal,” Jessica said. “There are a lot of other costs that come with wolf presence that aren't being covered.
The Bottom Line
“I want the public to know how taxing this is on ranchers emotionally,” Jessica said. “It's heartbreaking and financially bankrupting.”
These aren't people asking for handouts. Ranchers are among America's most self-reliant. What's different now is they're legally prohibited from defending themselves while bearing the full weight of a policy they didn't choose.
The wolves are coming. Policies aren't changing fast enough. But ranchers shouldn't face this alone.
Listen to the podcast at northstaterocks.com or on Apple, Spotify, Amazon, IHeartRadio, and Pandora.
and bring energy, experience and expertise to complete the simplest jobs efficiently, and overcome the largest obstacles with enthusiasm.
